What Are Silver Milk Spots and How Do They Influence the Value of Coins?

What are milk spots? Milk spots refer to pale, milky blemishes that can emerge on the surface of silver coins and bars. These marks resemble dried milk and exhibit varying sizes and shapes.

Milk spots can manifest on both bullion and Proof-finished coins. However, they are more frequently observed on silver bullion coins possessing a purity of 999.0 or higher, and are seldom found on older coins containing alloys.

Origin of milk spots: The prevalent belief is that milk spots might form during the manufacturing process due to the chemicals employed during minting and annealing.

Nevertheless, there isn’t a confirmed single cause for these persistent marks. Multiple factors, including interactions between the silver and contaminants in processing, handling, and storage, might contribute to their occurrence.

Milk spots materialize unpredictably, potentially appearing on silver coins days, weeks, months, or even years following minting.

Milk spots are fairly prevalent and are not isolated to a specific mint. They can affect not only silver coins but also bars.

Preventing milk spots: Regrettably, there’s no foolproof method for silver investors to prevent milk spots. Some investors believe prudent storage and handling practices can reduce the likelihood of spotting. Proper encapsulation within a container that minimizes exposure to air and elements can help prevent premature discoloration of silver coins and bars. However, if these marks do stem from production, some coins might still develop them eventually.

In recent times, The Royal Canadian Mint has addressed the milk spot issue and introduced a patented technology called MINTSHIELD™ to mitigate the root cause. This technology, a closely guarded secret, claims to significantly decrease the appearance of milk spots for years. Silver maple leaf bullion coins dated 2018 and beyond are now protected with MINTSHIELD™, which seems to have reduced milk spot occurrences in silver Maples.

The Perth Mint has also taken steps to identify and counter the milk spot problem, such as regular cleaning of filters to eliminate oil and water buildup, and replacement of air-conditioning filters to minimize airborne particles in coin production areas.

Impact on coin value: Milk spots should not impact the resale value of a silver bullion coin.

Bullion coins are primarily crafted for investment purposes and are valued based on the precious metal content they contain, rather than their condition or visual appeal. Regardless of any marks, an ounce of silver remains an ounce of silver.

However, collectors of Proof coins might be more concerned about milk spots, as these items often command higher prices due to their numismatic appeal, requiring coins to be in pristine condition.

Removal of milk spots: The recommended advice for removing milk spots from silver coins aligns with general cleaning practices and is best avoided if possible.

Given that milk spots don’t affect resale value negatively, it’s advisable to leave them be. Attempts to remove them could lead to coin damage, potentially replacing spots with scratches that worsen the coin’s appearance.

Some collectors have attempted spot removal using quality silver polishing cloths or gentle white pencil erasers. A chemical “silver dip” that removes a thin silver layer is another method, but it carries risks and isn’t recommended.

Future outlook: Milk spots have been a prominent subject among bullion investors and dealers globally. With mints now working to combat the issue, there’s hope that these marks may eventually be eradicated.

For now, experienced silver investors and collectors often accept milk spots as a common phenomenon, similar to how they view tarnishing, as indications of silver’s authenticity. Just as collectors today appreciate the aged patina of old silver coins, perhaps they may come to view milk spots similarly in the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Message Us Here